A worthy booker winner? The sense of an ending – Julian Barnes

There has been much debate as per normal as to whether Barnes deserved to win the Booker.  Much of it has centred around the fact that one of the judges Stella Rimmington praised  it as being “very readable”  Was this  a mortal sin? For some it certainly was, they  argued that being readable was not a criteria and it should be about creative skill and now there is talk of creating a new prize for writing.  Anyway for me the issue is whether he really deserved the prize or he was simply given it because he had been nominated three times previously.

The book like ‘Wuthering Heights’ or the  Sarah Waters ‘The Little Stranger‘  has an unreliable narrator.  Tony receives a bequest in the will of his ex-girlfriend Veronica’s mother and this leads him to start thinking about Veronica, and his school friend Adrian who  committed suicide.  Tony is eventually forced to  confront his role in this affair and to question his culpability.

The novel deals with the issue of our memories and how reliable they are.  It also makes frequent links to the nature of history and whether as Tony argues it is simply written not by the victors as  but is “simply the memories of the survivors”.   Adrian’s view however  is that it is “simply written at the point where the imperfections of memory meet the inadequacies of documentation”.    As a history teacher I found these questions very interesting and it led me to question about my own memories of past relationships and their accuracy.

Someone at our book club raised the question as to who was the father of Adrian.  Now I thought this was straight forward but it led to a bit of debate, so if anyone reads this let me know what you think.

According to the Man Booker website this is “a truly wonderful novel that will have the reader immersed in the story from the very first page”.  Now I didn’t experience this until about 15 pages, although admittedly the book is very short at only 150 pages.  A problem with the novel is that  despite knowing Tony’s memories are flawed Veronica still seems hideous.

Now the book was an interesting read, and at book club I did recognise it is at first deceptively simple but it becomes one of those stories that makes you think. I have always found Barnes to be a bit of a mixed bag; I loved ‘Arthur and George‘ but some of his others such as ‘A History of the World in 10½ chapters I found less interesting.  Overall for me an interesting and short read but not really a Booker winner.

Click here for a very funny digested read of the novel at the guardian

Read this for details of the Booker controversy http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2011/oct/18/booker-prize-julian-barnes-wins



Filed under Uncategorized

3 responses to “A worthy booker winner? The sense of an ending – Julian Barnes

  1. Yes, a worthy winner. Nicely concise and very thought-provoking

  2. “Reward of merit is not life’s business”

    Many days after reading this book, my mind still resonates with this quote. This book tells a story which may not be great but the soul of the book stays with you. It deals with a lot more than what meets the eye. The characters are deep and the protagonist might force you to rethink many events of your past. After reading this book, I reflected back multiple times on how I have retold and relived my stories. And how the way the truth might be completely different from the version I think I know.

    The style and flow of the book is simply superb. It’s difficult not to admire Adrian and his perspective of life. Again, the story may not be a crowd puller or the kind of the one you would expect with the narration of this level. But every page is worth the time spent in absorbing the depth of each sentence. Most of the verses are emotionally poignant sending the reader into a small introspective journey. It opens our eyes to the fact that the everyday events we take for granted somehow assume so much importance in the bigger picture.

    The book drives the point that what we remember from our memories is just our version of the events and there might be more to the whole story. The journey of knowing protagonist’s memories, perceptions of life and the way they change when he encounters the truth is an enriching one. The book is more than just 150 pages of a story; it’s also a lens our lives can use at some point or other.

    A must read for all those who are looking for a different kind of book which entertains and at the same time is not shallow.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s